{"id":"arxiv:2609.23957","kind":"preprint","title":"Divergent strategies and convergent outcomes in autonomous materials discovery","authors":["Jihan Kim"],"author_count":1,"year":2026,"published":"2026-09-21","venue":null,"cited_by":0,"doi":null,"arxiv_id":"2609.23957","nct_id":null,"source_url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/2609.23957","archive_url":"https://space-kitty.com/papers/arxiv:2609.23957","updated":"2026-09-21","pmid":null,"pmcid":null,"openalex_id":"W7214048595","pdf_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2609.23957","abstract":"Scientific agents are mostly evaluated on whether they complete tasks or recover known results; we instead study variation across repeated open-ended campaigns. Sixteen separately initialized sessions of one model-harness configuration received a frozen database of 12,499 metal-organic frameworks, a methane-storage objective, a pinned protocol and a one-week budget. Strategies diverged into four approaches spanning 100--5,000 screened structures, and eight built 2,253 hypothetical structures. Yet the agents recovered the same materials frontier near 200 cm^3/cm^3, and an independent calculation of the database's porous region found its nine best structures all among their reports. Enforced checks on half the agents raised fresh-run reproduction from one of eight to eight of eight but could not detectably improve conclusion validity, because fifteen of sixteen agents selected the same audit-excluded entry, an incomplete structure whose missing anions created artificial pore volume. Replicated agents thus reveal both robust conclusions and common-mode errors from shared inputs.","abstract_license":"CC0-1.0 (arXiv descriptive metadata)","license":null,"is_open_access":false,"retracted":false,"peer_reviewed":false,"categories":["cs.AI","cond-mat.mtrl-sci"],"details":null,"provenance":"arxiv","attribution":"Abstract: arXiv descriptive metadata (CC0). Thank you to arXiv for use of its open access interoperability. This service was not reviewed or approved by, nor does it necessarily express or reflect the policies or opinions of, arXiv.","topics":[{"slug":"room-temperature-claims","name":"Room-Temperature Superconductivity Claims & Replication","domain_slug":"superconductivity"}],"cited_in_dossiers":[]}